Edward Green; Square or round toed lasts for Derby/Bluchers

[Leather man]

Had what for was me a confusing conversation with the Edward Green shop. I've just ordered one of their new Autumn 2009 styles and asked about lasts. I was told they only come on one last. My order, Wells, a Derby/Blucher, comes on the 82 last - a sleek round toed last.



I was told that Derbys only suit round toed lasts and on pressing my question further was told that the 888 last only suits shoes with a fairly smooth, unpatterned front , or a sleek looking oxford with subdued patterning like Inverness.



I am rather bewildered as I have always thought the 888 last ( a smart square toed last) suits semi - brogued Derbys very well.



What do others think? Do you agree with the shop or do you have other views. I am told its all about asthetic balance.



If Tom Parks reads this I'd REALLY appreciate your view Tom. I was wanting to order Elmsley on 888 later in the year but am now unsure.



Thanks everyone in advance



LM